JUSTICE OR INJUSTICE - A mural depicting shooting victim Oscar Grant in an Oakland, CA underpass. Was the verdict racist, too lienient, or just a mess?

A few months ago, a white police officer in a transit station in Oakland, CA killed a young African American named Oscar Grant. The case became something of a local cause célèbre, causing the trial to be moved to Los Angles. The SoCal jury returned an involuntary manslaughter verdict yesterday, while later in the evening the streets back in Oakland were the scene of skirmishes between police and rioters enraged at what they believed was a racist verdict.

Even before the trial began, Oscar’s grieving family, and many others in Oakland, said that nothing short of a murder verdict would bring justice. Some were shouting for a murder conviction within hours of the killing and threatening violence if they didn’t get it.

Unfortunately, the case wasn’t clear-cut. Although the incident had been captured by several cell phones and witnessed by hundreds of people, it was impossible to tell conclusively why the officer shot Oscar. Oscar’s friends and family said it was a blatant example of a cop shooting a defenseless young black man in the back. After all, it’s happened many times before.

The cop’s defense team argued it was a horrific mistake of the cop confusing his Taser with his service weapon. After all, mistakes happen in the heat of a takedown. Both sides had excellent points, but by the time the jury reached a verdict, it was clear the whole affair had become less about the guilt or innocence of this cop and this victim and more about the horrible difficulty America has in dealing with its racism.

There’s little doubt there are race problems in this country, anyone who argues otherwise is, well, Rush Limbaugh. But, it’s equally true that every conflict between a minority person and a white person isn’t automatically racism. Sometimes people do bad things to each other or someone makes a tragic mistake. That doesn’t excuse their actions, but it doesn’t automatically make the actions racist either.

JUSTICE SERVED? - Racial tensions run high in Oakland, but did they reasonably apply to this case?

In this case, there are some valid reasons for believing it really was an accident. The cop had no clear racial motive to speak of. He didn’t have a track record of racism and it’s doubtful even the most virulent racist would choose to kill someone in full view of hundreds of people.

But then, there were troubling things about the cop’s story too. He couldn’t explain how he mistook his Taser for a pistol, even though the Taser and pistol required different release mechanisms, were substantially different in weight, and he did so after training designed to avoid the very thing that happened. True or not, the cop came off sounding like a man who couldn’t be trusted to do anything, including tell a plausible story.

The civil rights division of the DoJ is reviewing the case and there may be more deliberation, including a possible overturning of the verdict, to come. This is as it should be. This is how the system is supposed to work. A jury makes their best decision based on what they know. The judge apportions punishment as the law and situation dictates, and the DoJ checks everything out to make sure everyone has done their homework and gotten a chance to present it to the court. There’s nothing in there about everyone getting a verdict they want.

Oscar’s family, and many of the protesters at the riot, spoke of “the system” letting Oscar down. However, the system isn’t the problem in this case. The problem is that America’s racial tension makes it difficult to trust our system, regardless of what it does. And in doing so, makes the system weak and ensures undue biases effect the outcome. People will often come to different conclusions based on their own perceptions. It doesn’t really matter what a person’s perception is, it only matters what they do with that perception.

Clearly, there’s a dangerous perception gap between Americans of different colors.

Related articles by Zemanta

• Oscar Grant Supporters Loot Oakland (flystylelife.com)
• Oakland riots sparked by Oscar Grant verdict (abclocal.go.com)
• Theres No Justice, Just Us! Oakland Cop Gets Away with the Murder of Oscar Grant (fireandflames.blogsport.de)
• Oscar Grant, a Victim of American Fear (alternet.org)
• For Oscar Grant, Justice Demands More Than a Verdict (race.change.org)
• Oakland cops make arrests at verdict protest (msnbc.msn.com)

ARRGH! PREPARE FER BOARDIN' - Welcome to Peg Leg Pete's Perfect Peg Leg and Hook Emporium. This week only, get a parrot with every purchase.

The Internet Isn’t a Time Nor Place, It’s a State of Mind

• There are just so many reasons why frieinds don’t let friends go to Starbucks.
• David got off to an inauspicious start on Dancing with the Stars.
• Could this site BE any more annoying?
• Kevin was extremely excited by his odd hobby. Others were not so amused.
• GEICO was blamed for the Florida dog deaths.
• Team Gillette was determined to show their shaving technology was years ahead of their rival Schick.
• Po hadn’t heard about the dangers of smoking, so he happily puffed on.
• Watch out for the last step, it’s a doozy.
• Scientists believed that Keith Richards may have been the cause of hell freezing over.
• It was prom night and Julie just couldn’t go with a huge zit on her chin.
• In their defense, Pedobear was awfully cute.
• I don’t know, $20 million seems like chump change for a good acoustic kitty.
• At the end, it turned out Andrea had mistakenly knifed a PETA protestor in lambs clothing.
• Ashok’s mother accidentally scared him with a mirror when he was born.
• Hell, I’ve seen rats bigger than this in the NY City sewer system.
• Alright Maggot, drop and give me 20 boogers.

The Land of the Rising Sun

• Whenever you travel, remember to stop at a Barry White Inn.
• The Japanese are a passionate people.
• Betcha can’t eat just one.

Sex in the Blogosphere

• Just in case you were curious…
• I see expensive therapy in this boy’s future.
• The Massatuchetts legislature would be well served to get it’s mind out of the gutter.
• Many Republicans believe that the repeal of Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell would bring all sorts of lewd behavior out of the woodwork.
• Who knows what ugliness lurks under the burka?
• Unfortunately, a whole new industry of Viagra spam was also launched.
• As long as I don’t have to wear my hair iin a mullet, I’m so there.
• That’ll convince Jon not to dump any other women – that is if he can GET any more women.

The Hooterville Crime Blotter

• Roberta quickly discovered the crowd at the Live Nude Girls Club was harsh indeed.
• Jim got a bad case of cabin fever because of “snowmageddon”.
• Clearly, Ye got a little too excited by the Super Bowl.
• Kali had been beated senseless, but considered herself lucky she hadn’t been waterboarded to boot.
• Jim had a little Captain Morgan in him.
• Bucky was just upset because he lost his knife and was wicked hungry.
• The District Atorney will probably ask for the death penalty.
• Officers on vice patrol duty really though the shoes gave their hooker outfits jsut a smidge more authenticity. However, they had their dangers.
• Stephen loved the feel of a light breeze on his skin.
• They Phoenix police may have busted him, but he gave the TSA a great idea for airport security.

There’s a Thin Line Between Enrepeneur and Lunatic Inventor

• According to capitalist theories, the products exist because there’s a market for them. Scary thought, eh?
• Nothing spells welcome than 330 feet of industrial grade coir hair.
• Although many patients loved the hospital gown, some were disappointed they could no longer get that “free” feeling as they wandered the halls.
• This is where entrepeneurs cross the line into lunatic inventor territory.
• Walmart decided they would change their name and go after the hip hop market segment.
• Marian believed strongly in the philosophy, “hugs not slugs“.
• The makers of the Potty Putter changed their product’s name to Potty Pooper to avoid a trademark infringement.
• Next product: Crap-n-Panties for the woman who always wants that “live-in look”.
• They originally called the product Chastity Bone-O.

Ragin’ Robots

• Chucky was an imnportant technological achievement, but was still scary as hell.
• Sam worked for years to create the perfect duck that laid the golden egg before giving up before reaching his goal.

Related articles

• More Randomness (omnipotentpoobah.com)
• I Was There: “It Was The First Time I Actually Saw Women Making Out With Cars” (deadspin.com)
• Now, radio ads that mirror what you want (thoughtgadgets.com)
• Rare Snowflakes Start Falling From Miss. to Fla. (abcnews.go.com)
• Danielle Crittenden: Capital Snow Diaries III: “Safeway Is Decimated!” (huffingtonpost.com)
• Now This Is A Speech (dlisted.com)
• Johnny Depp Continues The Bromance, Directs Keith Richards Documentary!! (perezhilton.com)
• Joe Namath’s Labrador declared dangerous (thestar.com)
• 5 is enough, but Gillette upgrades razor, again (sfgate.com)
• Facebook offers a neat look at America (sharemarketing.wordpress.com)